False documents, lasting consequences: Understanding the impact of a SAFPS listing

The complaint

The case involved a consumer who discovered that they had been listed on the Southern African Fraud Prevention Service (SAFPS) database, which negatively affected their ability to access banking services. The consumer denied ever applying for vehicle finance or having any dealings with the bank and requested that their name be removed from the fraud database.

Bank’s response

The bank investigated the matter and found that a vehicle finance application had been submitted in June 2023 through a dealership using the consumer’s personal details, including their correct cell phone number and email address. As part of the application, bank statements were provided; however, upon verification with the issuing bank, it was confirmed that these statements had been altered and contained false information, including salary deposits that did not actually exist.

Based on the submission of fraudulent documents, the bank proceeded to list the consumer on the SAFPS database. The bank further indicated that all personal details on the application matched the consumer’s information and that there was no evidence to suggest that the consumer was a victim of identity theft or impersonation.

NFO investigation and outcome

The central issue requiring determination was whether the bank acted reasonably and within its contractual and fraud prevention obligations when it concluded that fraudulent or misleading documentation had been submitted and thereafter listed the complainant with SAFPS.

After considering the evidence, we found that the bank had acted within its rights and responsibilities in taking steps to prevent and mitigate fraud. Financial institutions may list individuals with the Southern African Fraud Prevention Service (SAFPS) where there is credible evidence of fraudulent activity. They are not required to notify the individual before submitting a listing.

A SAFPS fraud listing remains in place for a period of 10 years, after which it is automatically removed.

In the circumstances, we found no evidence of wrongdoing or maladministration on the part of the bank. We were therefore unable to recommend that the bank remove the listing.

Consequences of a SAFPS listing

A listing on the Southern African Fraud Prevention Service (SAFPS) database can have serious and far-reaching consequences for consumers, potentially affecting various aspects of their financial lives and future opportunities.

SAFPS is used by many major banks, insurers, credit providers and retailers to identify and prevent fraud. Consequently, a fraud listing may make it considerably more difficult for an individual to access certain financial products and services.

For example, consumers with a SAFPS listing may experience difficulties when applying to open bank accounts or obtain credit, including vehicle finance, personal loans, credit cards, store accounts and home loans. Financial institutions may regard a fraud listing as an indication of increased risk, which could negatively affect the outcome of an application.

A SAFPS listing may also affect employment opportunities. Certain employers conduct fraud and background checks as part of their recruitment processes, and a fraud listing may therefore have an adverse impact on an individual’s employment prospects.

Important consumer lessons

This case highlights the importance of protecting your personal information and acting honestly when applying for financial products and services. It also serves as a reminder that, although financial institutions may submit fraud listings where there is credible supporting evidence, they must have a proper factual basis for doing so. A bank’s right to submit a listing does not mean that every listing is automatically justified or beyond dispute.

Consumers should keep the following in mind:

  • Be honest when applying for credit: Never submit false, misleading or altered documents to support a credit application.
  • Protect your personal information: Keep your identity documents, identity number, bank statements and other sensitive personal information secure to prevent them from being misused.
  • Monitor your financial records: Regularly check your credit profile and fraud status to identify any irregularities.
  • Know your rights when disputing a listing: If you believe that a SAFPS listing is incorrect or unjustified, you may dispute it directly with SAFPS and the financial institution responsible for submitting it. The institution should be given an opportunity to consider the dispute and assess whether the listing remains justified.
  • Understand the long-term consequences: A fraud listing can have a significant impact on your ability to access financial services and may affect you for several years.

Dhirishka Maharajh-Ramnarayan
Senior Adjudicator
Banking Division

Looking for something specific?

[ivory-search id="7603" title="AJAX Search Form"]